Tops Families Upset by Payton Gendron's Court Appearance

Tops Families Upset by Payton Gendron’s Court Appearance

The appearance of the Tops shooter at Payton Gendron’s guilty plea on Monday morning was the most striking aspect of the proceedings, leaving the victims’ families with questions about the system and the shooter’s motivation.

“That’s how America treats young white men, right? the surviving child’s mother, Zeneta Everhart, said. This is how we like to keep it. When we display them, we make sure they don’t appear dangerous; this is repulsive.

The families of the victims figured Gendron, with his shaggy hair and an orange jumpsuit, would be in handcuffs. Contrary to popular belief, the 19-year-old who pleaded guilty to all 25 state counts was not the violent criminal described by witnesses. Courtroom proceedings were not recorded by any outside sources.

Mark Talley, the son of another victim, described the shooter as “you see him with a sixth-grade, middle-school haircut, clean shave, looking real scrawny and nervous.” “If that were my son, if that were Zaire, pictures of him would have been in a hoodie,” Everhart added. “That’s how we project black men in this country, and we clean up our young white kids.”

Must Check:


Some lawyers have speculated that Gendron’s appearance was tactical. Despite his guilty plea and the consequent mandatory life sentence without the possibility of parole under state law, he still faces the possibility of a death sentence under federal law.

“If you’re a competent defense attorney, you’re going to present your best foot forward,” criminal defense attorney Paul Cambria said. Hence, “you’ll have your client clean up nicely.”
While this is being interpreted by some as a deliberate tactic, Erie County Sheriff John Garcia has stated that the suspect’s appearance is not out of the ordinary.

He emphasized that inmates are free to decide for themselves whether or not they want to make use of the barber services. “From what I’ve seen of him recently, it’s clear that he got a haircut right before the court today.” The sheriff continued by saying that no matter how Gendron was portrayed, no one’s opinion would change.

Garcia stated, “A haircut and shave are not going to make up for killing 10 people. Regardless of how he may have seemed today, it makes no difference. Everyone, including myself, is aware of his status as a convicted killer.

Gendron’s parents made their first public statement, telling the AP that they are relieved their son will be punished as a result of his guilty plea. Pamela and Paul Gendron have said they “pray for healing for everyone affected.” They expressed gratitude to the law enforcement officers who conducted the investigation and promised to “continue to provide any assistance we can.”

In a statement emailed to The Associated Press, the family said, “We remain shocked and shattered to learn that our son was responsible for the hideous attack at the Tops grocery store on May 14, 2022.” This federal case against Gendron will continue until at least February when he is due back in court.